Talk:Christ ist erstanden (Johann Sebastian Bach)

From ChoralWiki
Jump to: navigation, search

Merge discussion

The editions on this page seem to be the same work as on Christ ist erstanden (Chorale) (Johann Sebastian Bach) but the editions on the latter have different titles to the title of the page ("Christ lag in Todesbanden", not "Christ ist erstanden") and the editions on this page... should the editions be kept on separate pages? --Bobnotts talk 00:40, 10 January 2008 (PST)

I support merging. Each editor's page appears to have 4 different arrangements. However, if you compare Claudio's 2nd arrangement with the top-most arrangement on the other editor's page, it is clearly the same song (the Alleluia... Kyrie eleison). The reason it's not obvious at first is because the 4 versions on each editor's pages set different parts of the piece, so at first it appears to be comparing apples and oranges. --Vaarky 23:07, 22 February 2009 (UTC)