Talk:The Goslings (John Frederick Bridge)

From ChoralWiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search

There is a load of typos in this which make it really hard for the pianist trying to sight-read through it. The most egregious ones are:

Bar 3 3rd beat piano r.h.: delete F

bar 6 4th beat piano l.h.: add flat to D

bar 19 1st beat piano r.h.: add natural to B

bar 20 1st beat piano r.h.: delete B

bar 25 2nd beat alto part & piano r.h.: F should be C (compare bar 2 and Novello edition)

bar 31 last quaver (eighth note) piano r.h.: add natural to B

bar 39 1st note piano l.h.: F should be E

bar 48 2nd beat alto part & piano r.h.: D should be C (compare bar 2 and Novello edition)

bar 64 3rd beat piano l.h.: B should be C

That's all I found on a single rehearsal. There may be others...


I found the following, mostly matching with the above:

Bar 7 the right-hand of the piano part should have a G as well as an E on the last quaver.

Bar 14 the piano part should have a pause (fermata).

Bar 19 the piano part hsould have a natural sign on the B.

Bar 22 the bass part is missing a pause sign (fermata).

Bar 31 the piano part should have a natural on the B in the last quaver.

Bar 36 the left-hand of the piano part should be a B flat as well as a C in the first two beats.

Bar 39 the left-hand of the piano part should have an E, not an F.

Bar 51 the soprano part does not match the piano part in the second beat, but I think the piano is correct, so they should be a quaver G in the soprano part.

Bar 64 the left-hand of the piano part should have a bottom C, not B flat in the last two beats.

Neilvh (talk) 22:03, 26 February 2017 (UTC)

Neil Hawes Musical Director, Whitton Choral Society, UK

The sub-title should be "Humorous" rather than "Humerous" !

Neilvh (talk) 10:47, 16 March 2017 (UTC)